Tuesday, December 17, 2024

2024 Fall Migration Banding Summary

The 2024 fall migration banding season at the Kiawah Island Banding Station (KIBS) concluded on Saturday, 30 November. Banding occurred at two sites on Kiawah Island: Captain Sams and Little Bear.  This was the 16th consecutive year of fall migration banding at the Captain Sams site with banding occurring daily during the last 13 years.  It was the 10th season for the Little Bear site, which we initiated during the fall of 2015.  The two sites are located at each end of the island about 8 miles apart (Captain Sams on the west end, Little Bear on the east end).  Both sites are situated in coastal scrub/shrub and high marsh habitats, however, the Little Bear site is in an earlier stage of succession.

Collectively, we banded 9,124 birds and had 2,447 recaptures of 106 different species.  Captain Sams had a substantial increase in the number of birds banded compared to last fall, while Little Bear experienced a small decrease. Combined, however, we banded 14% more birds than last year.

Overall, the average monthly temperature was consistent with the historical average.  However, the first half of November was 5.6 °F warmer than the historic average.  This season was also slightly drier, and we experienced less rain (18.7”) than normal (19.4”).  Most of the rain this season (12.8”) came in the first half of August prior to our banding season starting.  The first “cold” front arrived on 20 August. Unlike the last several years, cold fronts seemed to come in more regularity averaging about one per week through September and October.  Most of the cold fronts were weak or had weakened by the time they reached the Southeast. We experienced good movement of migrants with the passage of two strong cold fronts in September (9/9 and 9/19) and two in October (10/1 and 10/15).   As usual migration slowed down during November, but steady numbers of Yellow-rumped Warblers arrived all month long.   

It was an active Atlantic hurricane season with 18 named storms but only two affected our operations at KIBS.  Hurricane Debby made landfall in the Florida panhandle as a Category 1 on 5 August.  It weakened and moved up the coast making a second landfall on 8 August just north of Charleston, SC bringing with it 7” of rain, strong winds, and a 1 ft storm surge.  The rain flooded both stations for the start of the banding season but because Captain Sams is tidal, most of the water receded quickly only leaving 6-8” of water in the lower elevation areas of the station.  Little Bear on the other hand is situated in a basin that collects and holds water, and as a result had 12-18” of water throughout much of the site.  Hurricane Helene made landfall as a Category 4 in the Big Bend region of Florida on 26 September.  Helene weakened and quickly moved inland up into Georgia and western South Carolina.  While the effects of Helene were minimal in our area, we did receive enough rain to shut down banding operations for a day. 

CAPTAIN SAMS

Nets were open for a total of 105 days from 15 August - 30 November.  There were 3 days when banding did not occur because of weather: 9/7 (rain), 9/27 (Hurricane Helene; rain and wind), 11/7 (rain).   

We banded 5,779 new birds of 93 different species.  The most commonly banded species were Common Yellowthroat (1,520), Yellow-rumped Warbler (1,013), and Gray Catbird (767). Those three species combined made up 57.1% of all the birds banded this season.  After falling to the number 3 spot last year, Common Yellowthroats rushed to the top this year and increased by 82% from last year and 35% from the average since 2012.  This was the most Common Yellowthroats we have ever banded in one season.  Rebounding from a poor fall last year, Yellow-rumped Warblers increased by 93% this fall compared to last year and 31% compared to the average since 2012.  After topping the list last year, Gray Catbirds fell to third with a decrease of 18% from last year and 5% since 2012. 

The overall effort increased from 17,178.3 net-hours in 2023 to 17, 502.9 net-hours this year.  This difference is small, and we did have one additional day of banding this year.  

We banded 1,158 more birds this year compared to last year, and 1,028 birds more than the average for the previous 13 years.  The capture rate of new birds was 33.0 birds/100 net-hours. The capture rate increased by 6.1 birds/100 net-hours compared to last year but was still 4.8 birds/100 net-hours lower than the 13-year average of 37.8 birds/100 net-hours.  Our capture rate has decreased every year starting in 2012 except for 2017, 2019, 2022, and again this year when we experienced small increases from the previous year. The capture rate of recaptures is normally very consistent from year to year, however, this year the capture rate was 8.6 birds/100 net-hours which is 1.2 birds/100 net-hours lower than the average since 2012.

We had 1,506 recaptures this season compared to 1,292 recaptures from last year representing a 17% increase.  Recaptures can be divided into 3 categories: repeats (birds recaptured in the same season in which they were banded), returns (birds recaptured in a different season in which they were banded), and foreign recaptures (birds recaptured that were banded elsewhere). We had 1,279 repeats, 221 returns, and 6 foreign recaptures.  It is rare to catch a bird that was banded at another location but to have multiples in one season is even more extraordinary.

·         Worm-eating Warbler (9/9/24) – banded 9/22/20 in Key Biscayne, FL

·         Northern Waterthrush (9/22/24) – banded and nanotagged in New Jersey

·         Common Yellowthroat (9/17/24) – banded 8/31/24 in Cape May, NJ

·         Common Yellowthroat (9/22/24) – banded 9/9/24 in Cape May, NJ

·         Common Yellowthroat (10/8/24) – banded 5/17/19 in Newberry, MA

·         Common Yellowthroat (10/8/24) – banded 4/29/20 in Chestertown, MD

In addition to the foreign recaptures, we also captured 6 individuals that were banded at our Little Bear site that is located 8.8 miles to the east of Captain Sams.  Despite banding thousands of birds at each site during the fall, we normally have very little movement of the birds between them.  This year we captured a Northern Cardinal (10/21/21), Northern Waterthrush (9/25/22), Brown Thrasher (8/25/23), Gray Catbird (10/14/22), and 2 Song Sparrows (10/18/23, 11/8/23) that were originally banded at Little Bear on the date in paratheses.   

There were 12 days this fall when over 100 birds were banded including 2 days with at least 400 birds banded and 3 days with over 200 birds banded.  The best day of the season was on 20 September when we banded 438 birds.  Of those 438 birds, 223 of them were Common Yellowthroats!  The next two busiest days occurred on 15 October and 1 October when 400 and 296 birds were banded, respectively. Of the 400 birds banded on 15 October, 205 of those were Gray Catbirds! 

We had 23 regularly occurring species that exhibited record high numbers this season:  Yellow-billed Cuckoo (34*), Eastern Whip-poor-will (3), Yellow-bellied Sapsucker (14), Yellow-bellied Flycatcher (5), Eastern Phoebe (90), White-eyed Vireo (120), Brown Creeper (8), Winter Wren (3), Marsh Wren (6), Blue-gray Gnatcatcher (18), Golden-crowned Kinglet (28), Swainson’s Thrush (100), Chipping Sparrow (2*), White-crowned Sparrow (4), White-throated Sparrow (24), Swamp Sparrow (80), Black-and-white Warbler (49), Nashville Warbler (4), Common Yellowthroat (1,520), Cape May Warbler (65), Bay-breasted Warbler (7), Summer Tanager (9), Painted Bunting (221). Alternatively, we had one species that had record low numbers: Hooded Warbler (1*).  The * indicates species that tied the record high or low.   

Some other rare and notable species that were banded this fall include: Red-shouldered Hawk (1; 3 previous), Sedge Wren (1; 4 previous), Grasshopper Sparrow (1; 3 previous), Nelson’s Sparrow (1; 1 previous).

Species notably absent this year included: Mourning Dove (36 total, average 2.8/year), Cooper’s Hawk (12 total, average 0.9 year), Eastern Bluebird (6 total, average 0.5/year), Clay-colored Sparrow (13 total, average 1.0/year), Field Sparrow (23 total, average 1.8/year), Lincoln’s Sparrow (5 total, average 0.4/year).     

We banded 5 species that have never been banded before: Barred Owl, Dusky Flycatcher, Bicknell’s Thrush (2), Cerulean Warbler, and Black-headed Grosbeak.  The Dusky Flycatcher is a western species that breeds wests of the Rocky Mountains and winters in Mexico.  While there have been some records of Dusky Flycatchers in the east, this is the first one for South Carolina.  Black-headed Grosbeak is another species that breeds in the western US and winters in Mexico however it is more prone to wander with hundreds of records throughout the eastern US. This appears to be the 4th record for South Carolina and the first since 1978.  Bicknell’s Thrush is an eastern species with a very restricted range occupying disturbed mountaintop coniferous forest in the northeastern US during the breeding season and wintering in the Greater Antilles.  While Bicknell’s Thrushes do occur in South Carolina during migration, they look identical to the Gray-cheeked Thrush which makes identifying them in the field impossible.  Only with measurements or (a voice recording) can Bicknell’s Thrush be identified outside of the breeding range.  Of the 37 species of wood-warblers that regularly occur in eastern North America, the Cerulean Warbler was the only one we had not banded yet.  Ceruleans are rare along the east coast and mainly migrant inland crossing the Gulf of Mexico to South America for the winter.         

We hosted 4 groups this year including the Kiawah Island Natural History Group (19 September), the Seabrook Island Birders (7 October), the SC Master Naturalist Program (8 October), and the naturalists from the Kiawah Island Golf Resort (21 November). 

Top 10 Species Banded at Captain Sams

1. Common Yellowthroat (1,520)

2. Yellow-rumped Warbler (1,013)

3. Gray Catbird (767)

4.  American Redstart (265)

5. Painted Bunting (221)

6. Red-eyed Vireo (185)

7. Palm Warbler (161)

8. Ruby-crowned Kinglet (134)

9. White-eyed Vireo (120)

10. Northern Waterthrush (114)

LITTLE BEAR

Nets were open for a total of 80 days from 22 August - 15 November. There were 5 days cancelled due to weather: 9/7 (rain), 9/16 (Tropical Cyclone #8; wind), 9/27 (Hurricane Helene; wind and rain), 10/10 (wind and rain), and 11/7 (rain). Little Bear was closed for an additional day (10/18) due to insufficient staffing.     

We banded 3,345 new birds of 87 different species.  The most commonly banded species were Common Yellowthroat (825), Gray Catbird (547), and Yellow-rumped Warbler (290). Those three species combined made up 50% of all the birds banded this season.  It was a good year for Common Yellowthroats with a 56% increase compared to last fall and a 35% increase over the average since 2015.  Alternatively, Gray Catbird numbers exhibited a 28% decrease from last fall and a 16% decrease on the 10-year average. Jumping back into the 3rd spot this year, Yellow-rumped Warblers numbers were almost identical to last year but up 8.6% over the 10-year average. Palm Warblers fell out of the top 3 down to 5 this year with a 60% decrease from last year while Painted Buntings landed in 4th with an 186% increase from last year.       

We logged 9,924.0 net-hours at Little Bear this fall – an increase from 9,260.1 net-hours in 2023.  We banded one more day than last fall and added one new net (net 26).  The new net was added to mitigate some of the loss of vegetation surrounding several of our wetland nets.  Excessive flooding and saltwater intrusion have reduced the vegetation in that area severely to the point where a couple nets have very little cover nearby. 

We banded 35 less birds this year compared to last year, but 373 more birds than the average since 2015.  Little Bear’s capture rate of new birds decreased by 8% from 36.5 birds/100 net-hours in 2023 to 33.7 in 2024.  Similarly, the capture rate decreased by 12.5% compared to the average over the last 10 years. The capture rate of recaptures was up 20% from last year but right in line with the 10-year average.     



We had 941 recaptures this season, which is much higher than the 729 recaptures from last year.  We had 827 repeats, 112 returns, and 1 foreign recapture.  The foreign recapture was a Gray Catbird, however, at the time of this report, the banding date and location is unknown. 

There were 8 days when over 100 birds were banded including 1 day with at least 200 birds banded.  Last year, we had 10 days over 100 birds and two 200-bird days.  The best day of the season was on 15 October when we banded 200 birds and had 13 recaptures.  Of the 200 birds, 103 of them were Gray Catbirds!  The next two busiest days occurred on 2 October and 9 September when 177 and 146 birds were banded, respectively. 

Several species exhibited record high numbers this season:  Yellow-crowned Night Heron (2), Chuck-wills-widow (2*), Downy Woodpecker (10), Eastern Wood-Pewee (10), Acadian Flycatcher (2), Least Flycatcher (2), Eastern Phoebe (54), Brown Creeper (3), Golden-crowned Kinglet (12),Veery (16), White-throated Sparrow (6*), Song Sparrow (41), Swamp Sparrow (77), Cape May Warbler (61), Bay-breasted Warbler (3*), Summer Tanager (2*), Painted Bunting (286).  Species that had record low numbers included: Eastern Towhee (1), Yellow-breasted Chat (5*), Baltimore Oriole (1*), Indigo Bunting (9). The * indicates species that tied the record high or low.  

Some other rare and notable species banded included: Bell’s Vireo (1; 1 previous), Winter Wren (1; 4 previous), Clay-colored Sparrow (1; 5 previous), Dark-eyed Junco (1; 2 previous), Kentucky Warbler (1; 1 previous), Rose-breasted Grosbeak (2; 1 previous). 

Species notably absent included Eastern Screech Owl (16 total; 1.6/year), Sharp-shinned Hawk (11 total; average 1.1/year), American Robin (9 total; 0.9/year), Chipping Sparrow (8 total; 0.8/year), Lincoln’s Sparrow (8 total; 0.8/year).

We did not band any new species this year at Little Bear.

Top 10 Species Banded at Little Bear

1. Common Yellowthroat (825)

2. Gray Catbird (547)

3. Yellow-rumped Warber (290)

4. Painted Bunting (286)

5. Palm Warbler (159)

6. Northern Waterthrush (118)

7. American Redstart (116)

8. Red-eyed Vireo (88)

9. Swamp Sparrow (77)

10. White-eyed Vireo (76)

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

Without the cooperation of many people and entities, this work would not be possible.  The success of this project relies on their commitment, and I owe a debt of gratitude to everyone involved. 

I'd like to thank my awesome team of seasonal banding assistants (Kristin Attinger, Natalie Miller, Noah Nei, and Lisa Viviano).  Their hard work over the course of this long season was outstanding.  It was a great season, and I would like to wish them all the very best of luck in the future.  I’d also like to thank Michael Gamble, who was a former seasonal banding assistant from 2015-2018 but is now a full-time biologist with the Town of Kiawah Island. After 7 fall seasons, I am sad to say that Kirstin will not be returning in 2025, but I am happy to report that she has accepted a full-time biologist position.  She will be missed, and I wish her the best of luck with her new job.

 

From left to right: Lisa Viviano, Noah Nei, Michael Gamble, Aaron Given, Natalie Miller, Kristin Attinger

I'd like to acknowledge the Town of Kiawah Island for providing funding for equipment, and stipends and housing for the banding assistants.  Thanks to the Kiawah Partners and the Bear Island Holding Trust for allowing access to their property for banding.

Nancy Raginski (92.7), David McLean (36.4), Ann McLean (36.4), Peg Ackerson (25.8), Andy Thiede (25.8), Garrett Rhyne (18.7), Adam Wolf (18.0), Molly Kilper (12.5), and Aidan Given (12.0) all donated a considerable amount of their time (more than 10 hours) to help at the banding station.  We also had several volunteers that came out for just the day. I’d like to thank all the volunteers that made it out this year. Because of their help, we can operate a more efficient banding station.

Banding Statistics

Captain Sams

Little Bear

Total

# of Birds Banded

5,779

3,345

9,124

# of Recaptures

1,506

941

2,447

# of Species

93

87

106

Effort (net-hours)

17,502.9

9,924.0

27,426.9

Capture Rate (birds/100 net-hours)

41.6

43.2

42.2

Capture Rate of New Birds (birds/100 nh)

33.0

33.7

33.2

Capture Rate of Recaptures (birds/100 nh)

8.6

9.5

8.9

# of Nets

32

26

58

# of Days Operated

105

80

-

Dates of Operation

8/15-11/30

8/22-11/15

-


Species

Captain Sams

Little Bear

New

Recapture

New

 Recapture

Mourning Dove

-

-

1

-

Yellow-billed Cuckoo

34

4

22

4

Green Heron

-

-

6

-

Yellow-crowned Night Heron

-

-

2

-

Chuck-will's-widow

1

-

2

-

Eastern Whip-poor-will

3

-

-

-

Sharp-shinned Hawk

1

-

-

1

Cooper's Hawk

-

-

1

-

Red-shouldered Hawk

1

-

-

-

Eastern Screech-Owl

1

-

-

-

Barred Owl

1

-

-

-

Belted Kingfisher

-

-

1

-

Yellow-bellied Sapsucker

14

1

4

-

Downy Woodpecker

5

17

10

11

Northern Flicker

1

-

1

-

Eastern Wood-Pewee

8

-

10

-

Yellow-bellied Flycatcher

5

3

1

-

Acadian Flycatcher

2

-

2

-

"Traill's" Flycatcher

25

1

15

-

Least Flycatcher

2

-

2

-

Dusky Flycatcher

1

-

-

-

Eastern Phoebe

90

9

54

-

Great Crested Flycatcher

3

1

-

-

Eastern Kingbird

1

-

2

-

White-eyed Vireo

120

54

76

2

Bell's Vireo

-

-

1

-

Blue-headed vireo

5

1

2

-

Red-eyed Vireo

185

3

88

5

Carolina Chickadee

7

30

8

34

Tufted Titmouse

-

-

2

1

Tree Swallow

4

-

-

-

Golden-crowned Kinglet

28

10

12

-

Ruby-crowned Kinget

134

44

39

3

Brown Creeper

8

2

3

-

Blue-gray Gnatcatcher

18

7

1

-

House Wren

53

21

60

13

Winter Wren

3

-

1

-

Sedge Wren

1

1

-

-

Marsh Wren

6

-

2

-

Carolina Wren

5

23

15

42

Gray Catbird

767

372

547

281

Brown Thrasher

10

11

7

8

Northern Mockingbird

9

1

7

4

Veery

22

2

16

-

Gray-cheeked Thrush

3

-

2

-

Bicknell's Thrush

2

-

-

-

Swainson's Thrush

100

2

26

-

Hermit Thrush

30

34

9

-

Wood Thrush

3

-

3

1

American Robin

6

-

-

-

House Finch

16

1

1

-

American Goldfinch

7

-

-

-

Grasshopper Sparrow

1

1

-

-

Chipping Sparrow

2

-

-

-

Clay-colored Sparrow

-

-

1

-

Dark-eyed Junco

-

-

1

-

White-crowned Sparrow

4

-

1

-

White-throated Sparrow

24

3

6

1

Seaside Sparrow

-

-

1

-

Nelson's Sparrow

1

-

-

-

Saltmarsh Sparrow

1

-

1

2

Savannah Sparrow

2

1

2

-

Song Sparrow

49

18

41

10

Swamp Sparrow

80

33

77

27

Eastern Towhee

7

2

1

6

Yellow-breasted Chat

6

3

5

1

Baltimore Oriole

-

-

1

-

Ovenbird

43

22

22

1

Worm-eating Warbler

6

1

3

-

Northern Waterthrush

114

4

118

33

Black-and-white Warbler

49

17

19

-

Prothonotary Warbler

9

1

3

-

Swainson's Warbler

1

-

2

2

Tennessee Warbler

7

-

1

-

Orange-crowned Warbler

20

4

13

-

Nashville Warbler

4

-

1

-

Kentucky Warbler

-

-

1

-

Common Yellowthroat

1,520

210

825

77

Hooded Warbler

1

-

2

-

American Redstart

265

25

116

10

Cape May Warbler

65

4

61

2

Cerulean Warbler

1

-

-

-

Northern Parula

33

6

14

1

Magnolia Warbler

7

-

6

-

Bay-breasted Warbler

7

-

3

-

Blackburnian Warbler

-

-

1

-

Yellow Warbler

38

1

38

3

Chestnut-sided Warbler

2

-

2

-

Blackpoll Warbler

4

-

2

-

Black-throated Blue Warbler

86

13

34

-

Palm Warbler

161

6

159

-

Pine Warbler

3

1

2

-

Yellow-rumped Warbler (Myrtle)

1,013

209

290

9

Yellow-throated Warbler

1

-

1

-

Prairie Warbler

95

11

72

3

Black-throated Green Warbler

1

-

-

-

Canada Warber

1

-

-

-

Wilson's Warbler

1

-

-

-

Summer Tanager

9

-

2

-

Scarlet Tanager

5

-

2

-

Northern Cardinal

21

79

30

60

Rose-breasted Grosbeak

1

-

2

-

Black-headed Grosbeak

1

-

-

-

Blue Grosbeak

1

-

1

-

Indigo Bunting

34

1

9

-

Painted Bunting

221

175

286

283

Note:  All data is preliminary until it has has been thoroughly proofed.